Wednesday, September 5, 2007

Differences Between Appreciative Inquiry and Problem-Oriented Approach

Neil Ford has shared his point of view on Charles Elliott’s Appreciative Inquiry and the problem-oriented approach. Through reading, I had drawn up the differences between these 2 approaches:

Appreciative Inquiry

Problem-Oriented Approach

  • Help people to understand their strengths, analyze their options, plan effectively and participate more equally in decision-making.
  • Help people to identify their achievement.
  • Creates a positive development pathway.
  • Encourages people to think deeply about the ways they would like to develop.
  • Help people to identify problems, resource constraints and unmet basic needs.
  • Fix the problems.
  • Is logical and efficient.
  • Establish the sense of dependency.
  • Sustainability is difficult to achieve.

Normally, people will become loss when facing problems in lives. They tend to blame themselves and think negatively. Frequently, people will use the problem-oriented approach to solve the problems. During the process, people are more looking for the bad sides and the limitations of themselves. Even though this approach is logic and effective, but it is difficult to sustain and lead people to become dependency. Whereas Elliott’s Appreciative Inquiry is to guide people to think on the other way round when encounter obstacles in life. From the above, it is clearly showed that the Appreciative Inquiry is emphasis on strengths and achievements. This approach leads people to be aware of their strengths and goals to achieve. It also requires the participation from clients in decision-making process. People will become more independent and confident after experience this approach since Appreciative Inquiry helps them to create a positive development pathway.

I still remember Professor Dr. Othman Mahamed once said that the multitasking is lacking in the practitioners. For him, it is not sufficient to use only a theory or method, but we should apply what we had learnt. I do agree with Professor Dr. Othman. We should not be too rigid and only stick with a theory or method. Somehow each theory or method has their strong points which can help us to cope with different situations or clients. As a future counselor or consultant, is good to equip myself with different theories or approaches in order to assist my clients to the appropriate pathway flexibly.

1 comment:

sally lee said...

Dear sis Wedny,
Thanks for sharing this information with us. I agree with your view and i found it is very useful. Solving problem is important the most important is the development of a human being. Keep up the good work!