Thursday, September 27, 2007

Enduring Principles of Mental Health Consultation (Gerald Caplan and Ruth B. Caplan

Assalamualaikum and good morning...I just want to share some crucial thing about mental health consultation. It could be useful to us and perhaps can give further understanding about the essence of mental health consultation.
In exploring the evolution of mental health consultation, one might profitably begin by asking which of its elements have stood the test of time. Over 30 years of additional experience in a variety of settings suggests that consultants should adhere to the following principles:
1. Guide the development of consultation by understanding its ecological field. A consultation effort will be hampered unless an interconnected field of forces is explored and monitored. This field consists of the consultee and consultant organizations; the consultant and consultee individuals; community; the client and the client's family; as well as the interplay of historical, sociocultural, and psychosocial forces.
2. Explicate all consultation contracts. Consultation must be formalized through successive agreements between the consultants and consultee institutions in order to fulfill the professional missions of both institutions. Otherwise, consultation interactions may deteriorate into meaningless talk that sooner or later is discarded.
3. Keep the consultant relationship noncoercive. The coordinate, nonhierarchical power relationship is the cornerstone of the Caplanian approach. When the consultee is free to accept or reject whatever the consultant says, the odds are greater that he or she will actively choose as his or her own those ideas that make sense in resolving the presenting problems.
4. Promote consultee- centered consultation. The adoption of a consultee-centered (versus client-centered) approach focuses the attention of the consultant on remedying shortcomings in the consultee instead of just on the problems of client. Often, elements of the case are detected that have subjective implications for the consultee-the so-called theme interference. Once the consultant has identified a theme, he or she is in position to help the consultee to overcome it.
5. Avoid uncovering types of psychotherapy. We have always maintained that the consultant should not use the method of interpretation associated with insight-oriented psychotherapy. Drawing attention to the specific personal source of the consultee's work difficulty is a cardinal error, as it negates the coordinate, nonhierarchical relationship and weakens the consultee's unconcious defenses against rejected ideas.
6. Use the displacement object. A consultee may become overly involved and therefore, express his or her own inner conflicts by identifying personally with various elements in the client's drama. The consultant can capitalize on this situation by sending potent messages to the consultee-not by confronting him or her, as some consultation expert advocate, but by focusing on the client-related elements to help the consultee overcome irrational expectations. This technique may be "manipulative" but we regard it as wholly positive and supportive.
7. Foster orderly reflection. Unhurried, systematic reflection during consultation increases the consultee's awareness of the range of options available and counteracts premature, emotionally based closure.
8. Widen frames of reference. Central to the effectiveness of mental health consultation is the aid the consultant can offer by analyzing the consultee's work problem within interrelated contexts (i.e., intrapsychic, interpersonal and institutional psychosocial systems of client, consultee and consultant).
9. Train those who consult to be consultants. Consultation is a method of professional functioning with a separate body of concepts and techniques; it is neither modified counseling nor watered-down psychoanalysis. Consultation skills must be taught.

No comments: