Monday, October 1, 2007

Culturally Competent Consultation across Problem-Solving Stages

The problem-solving process is the essence of consultation and typically follows five stages (Zins & Erchul, 2000). First, a strong collaborative relationship is established. Second, the problem is defined in clear, concise, and measurable terms. Third, goals for intervention are established and the intervention is designed. Fourth, the intervention is implemented. Fifth, the effectiveness of the intervention is monitored and altered as necessary. Cultural issues may emerge during any of these stages. The following points were adapted from Sheridan (2000) unless otherwise noted.

Establish a Cooperative Partnership
  • A key aspect for creating a strong partnership is developing a mutual sense of trust and respect, which requires valuing cultural differences and viewpoints.
  • It is important to develop a sense of shared ownership. This may be difficult for individuals whose cultural background has taught them to defer to authority. For instance, Hispanic parents, due to their respect for authority, often have difficulty collaboratively participating in the educational decision making process and sometimes go along with suggestions they do not agree with or do not fully understand (Correa & Tulbert, 1993).
  • When collaborating, take into consideration how parents from diverse cultures view collaboration in schools. Parents may define collaboration differently ranging from cooperating to becoming full decision-making partners in the process (Lopez & Truesdell, in press).


    Problem Definition & Analysis
  • It is vitally important to not allow cultural differences to be construed as the problem. However, cultural differences must be recognized and acknowledged during the problem definition stage so that appropriate interventions can be developed.
  • Recognize that differences in values may influence the perception of the problem behavior and that a traditional viewpoint that the problem rests within the child may cause discomfort. Avoid labeling or categorizing deficiencies. Instead, focus on specific behaviors and reframe the problem as a "mismatch" between the child, home and school.
  • The consultant and consultee must look at the learner's cultural and linguistic background as well as their educational background. For example, within an instructional context, the consultant and consultee should look at the delivery of instruction within a multicultural context and examine whether the learner has the background knowledge required to complete the task (Lopez & Truesdell, in press).
  • When working with families who are not proficient in English, allow additional time to communicate through interpreters to determine families' concerns, priorities and resources (Lopez, 2000).
  • It is important to recognize that the behavioral scrutiny often required in data collection may be viewed as an invasion of privacy in some cultures. Consultants should openly discuss the contribution data make toward identifying the problem in concise and measurable terms and adjust the data collection process to align with a particular family's view when possible.
  • Finally, recognize that a consulting school psychologist's attempts to self-monitor their actions may be seen as inappropriate. While a consulting school psychologist may wish to acknowledge a lack of cultural knowledge or potential bias related to the case, this information may not be well received by those who frown on sharing perceived weaknesses outside of one's family.

Goal and Intervention Development
  • Cultural differences may lead to mismatched goals and expectations. Offer school personnel and parents opportunities to develop goals that compliment one another, yet at the same time are consistent with their preferred goals.
  • Explore the possibility of a mismatch between common behavioral interventions and the consultee's acceptance of those procedures. For example, a teacher and school psychologist may wish to implement a behavioral plan in the home and school that includes reinforcers for appropriate behavior, but the parents, due to cultural differences, disagree with the use of reinforcers. This intervention will not be successful unless all parties reach a compromise regarding the use of reinforcers.
  • Recognize that successful implementation of an intervention is linked to the match between the design of the intervention and the cultural realities of the home and/or school. Considerations such as time and material resources must be taken into account during intervention development in order for the intervention to be successful.

Intervention Implementation
  • Treatment integrity will be maximized if the intervention's goals and plan are developed in a culturally sensitive and cooperative manner.
  • Problems with implementation may be linked to unidentified variables. Even careful, culturally competent consultants will sometimes overlook an implementation barrier that is linked to a cultural or linguistic difference. When interventions are not being implemented according to plan, potential barriers should be openly explored.

Intervention Evaluation
  • It is vitally important to ensure consultees do not feel judged negatively if goals are not met. Instead, acknowledge that the goals have not yet been met and collectively consider barriers to treatment success, and whether strategies should be modified or if new interventions should be designed and attempted.
  • At the conclusion of the consultation, work to establish systems of support that will help sustain intervention success over time. This is particularly important when working with families. Families should be left with the sense that they are a collaborative partner with the school in the education of their child and that their input will be valued in the future.

BACK TO BASIC2

MODELS OF CONSULTATION


ideas:

Mental Health Consultation (( More on internal(mental health), Human service personnel, &improve functioning=effective))Caplan
Behavioral ( overt Behavior , emphasis on assessment&evaluate)John Watson
Organizational Consultation ( Organizational issues-to improve=effectiveness )Edgar Schein


LEARNING AND SKILL DEVELOPMENT

Dear friends, this information may help all of us how to deal with different background, culture, language diverse clients among consultants, consultees, teachers, family, and administrators.

"There are two ways of exerting one's strength: one is pushing down, the other is pulling up."
Booker T. Washington (Post-Civil War author, educator, and leader, 1856-1915)

Consultants

In order to practice in a culturally competent manner, consulting school psychologists must understand their own culture and how it impacts others, must respect and value other cultures, and must learn how to design and implement culturally appropriate interventions. School psychologists must also develop an understanding of how to build bridges across cultural differences while recognizing that there are individual differences within cultural groups (Ingraham, 2000). Learning to frame the problem and the consultation process in a way that values multiple perspectives and creates emotional safety and motivational support is also a key.
Consulting school psychologists must understand the culture of the school and the school as a system. This involves developing an awareness of the school in terms of attitudes and beliefs about culturally and linguistically diverse children (Lopez & Truesdell, in press). Consultants must also understand that policies and norms within the system may have a direct influence on the quality and types of services provided to students. Culturally and linguistically diverse students are often provided multiple services that are delivered across programs and staff in schools (e.g., English language learners may receive English as a second language, bilingual education, and bilingual special education services). In order to effectively coordinate service delivery, an understanding of how those services are delivered must be developed so that consistent interventions and supports can be implemented across programs.

Consultees

School psychologists must not only strive to increase their own knowledge, skills, and objectivity as they relate to working with culturally diverse populations, they must also encourage and inspire individuals and the teams they work with to do the same. The specific goals for consultee learning and development may vary depending on whether the consultee is a teacher, family member or administrator.

Teachers
It is vitally important that teachers and other school personnel begin to recognize and decrease the tendency to filter perceptions through stereotypes, overemphasize culture, or take a color-blind approach (Ingraham, 2000). One way consulting school psychologists can help school personnel grow in this area is to point out inaccurate perceptions that are held about the child or family. For instance, a teacher may comment that a student with limited English proficiency is not making sufficient reading progress because nobody at home is reading to the student. Comments such as these imply that the family does not want to help the child, when in fact it may be that parents feel uncomfortable reading to the child due to linguistic differences or do not understand the teacher's expectations for working with the child at home. In cases such as these, school psychologists and teachers can work together to find creative ways that family members can become more involved in the child's educational efforts.

Families
Consultants should help families gain the knowledge and skills they need to be a proactive force in the educational success of their children. Often families want to do more to help their child succeed in school but lack specific knowledge regarding how to help or have had negative experiences with schooling here or in their home culture that make them more likely to avoid home-school collaboration. In addition, families often need information to help bridge the gap between home and school in terms of academic expectations, homework, and philosophies about school-home interaction. Families who have newly immigrated to the U.S. also may need specific information about the educational system and the district's standards before fully understanding how to work with the school to best help their child.

Administrators
Consultants periodically consult with administrators on systemic issues related to cultural diversity. Traditionally, school success has been defined in terms of a White, middle class norm and students whose realities differ from this norm are generally required to make adjustments to achieve educational success (Lee, 2001). When culturally diverse students are not meeting school norms on a regular basis, consultants should help administrators look for systemic barriers such as policies, norms, and communication patterns that may be interfering with a high quality education for all children. One way to overcome these barriers is to implement professional development experiences for teachers and other school personnel on culturally competent practices. Another potential intervention is to collaborate with administrators and community stakeholders on joint initiatives. For instance, culturally diverse individuals from the community could come into the school as tutors, classroom presenters, assembly speakers, or experts for professional development workshops.

prevention of bullying

Recently, I read an article on newspaper about the bullying case again. One girl was beating by other 6 or 7 girls in the school at Puchong. Children's safety is seen to be one of the main concerns parents and teachers have today.
Educators want their students to be safe at school, and at the playground or even other places. The following tips may help you if one of your students is being bullied or may prevent your students from ever becoming victims of bullying.
Try to teach your students:
1) They should not carry a large amount of money.2) Remind them not to brag about owning expensive things like a Discman or electronic games.3) In the schoolyard, students should stay where most of the kids are playing. (Bullies don't like to have witnesses.)4) They should avoid walking alone. If possible, they should try to walk to and from school with good friends.5) If a schoolmate hits a student, he/she should tell a supervisor or a teacher immediately.6) In the school bus, a student who feels in danger of being bullied should try to sit near the bus driver.7) When using public transit, a student who feels in danger of being bullied should try to sit near other adults.
If every students can try they best to follow these tips, I believe that the amount of bullying cases will decrease slowly and slowly.

conjoint behavioral consultation

Conjoint Behavioral Consultation followed a four stage problem solving model such as conjoint problem identification, problem analysis, plan implementation and plan evaluation. CBC consultation occurred when parents and teachers serving as co-consultees in the same meetings.
By using the Conjoint Behavioral Consultation process in our consultation, it can enhance the awareness of teachers of the student’s differences. Besides that, it can also foster effectiveness of home-school relationships, assisting parents to understand differences and similarities among themselves and the larger school culture, building trust among parties and last one is developing shared commitments to student success.

Learning Disabilities

For my opinion as a teacher, I can see that many students having the learning disabilities problem in our society. Because of this problem, they feel difficult when learning in the class. Day by day, they will feel bored and started to create many social problems like truancy, bully, vandalism and more because of depression, anger, lonely, lost of love and anxiety.
The factors are mostly because lacking attention by parents and sensitivity of teachers in school. We cannot deny that children are curious creatures; they like to know everything things by asking and asking until they get the answer. But many parents in our modern society just concentrate on their work and didn’t pay more attention to teach their children and as a result the children will become reluctant to talk and ask.
Furthermore, the teacher teaches in school base on subject-centered. They just care to finish their syllabus and didn’t care about those students who have the learning disabilities’ problem. Even that they don’t want to change the way of teaching when they knew that this approach is not interactive for students. That’s why our children will create more social problem in school or outside the school.
Lastly, I hope that parents and teachers can consider the seriousness of this problem. If the parents and teachers can pay a little more attention to our children, I am sure that they won’t be able to have this problem and we don’t even need this collaboration approach for these children.

Culturally Competent services

Our country Malaysia is cultural diversity society. Thus, it is important to school-based consultant to understand well each of the cultural in order to reduce the misunderstanding of teacher when in the school. To provide culturally competent services in school effectively, the schools and the school personnel should aware of this few steps.
Firstly, it is important for school personnel to identify what cultural groups are represented in the school by observation and questioning. Secondly, the schools have to designate our school-based consultant to concern about the behavior and academic achievement of students from culturally or linguistically diverse backgrounds. At the same time, they must understand their own culture and how it affects others in order to learn how to design and implement culturally appropriate assessments and interventions.
After that, it is necessary to establish a pool of community consultants and assistants for some big schools as potential consultants and evaluation assistants can provide you insight of the specific cultural or linguistic group and provide a target student or family with information regarding the mainstream culture and language of the school’s community.
Then, the problem-solving process is the essence of assessment and consultation. In this stage, principals and their designees work collaboratively with teachers and parents who are seeking assistance in working effectively with students from culturally and linguistically diverse backgrounds.
The final step is the evaluation process. When assessing students from culturally or linguistically different backgrounds the use of standardized nonverbal cognitive and translated tests is recommended. Furthermore, an important part of the evaluation process is determining the need for a language assessment and what languages need to be assessed. Language evaluation should included assessment of speaking, reading and writing abilities. Additionally, the assessment team should recognize limitations in all report and consider what role language and culture and social history factors play in the results and observations of the student from diversity backgrounds.

Developmental Counseling and Therapy

Recently, our Malaysia’s teachers have facing the same problem that is – stress. Unfortunately, they refuse to seek for help directly to release their stress. Not like other country, once the teachers feel stress related to a school’s problems, they may seek for help immediately.
Thus, we need to apply the DCT therapy in our Malaysia because written referral documents are one way that school counselors encourage teachers to communicate their needs, considering both the content and stylistic aspects of these student referral documents in the context of historical referral data from each teacher might be helpful determining when to reach out to teachers and offer consultation.
When teachers report feeling stress because of students’ behaviors or classroom situations, it may be an indicator that they are not able to consider the situation from enough modalities. The DCT – based consultation model is designed to increase teachers’ access to cognitive developmental modalities so they may successfully respond to individual students, decrease their own stress and manage the classroom management.
The first step of the DCT – based consultation is accessing the current modality that teacher uses to describe a student’s behavior. The second step involves determining which modality might help the teacher to understand the situation to effect change in the classroom environment. The last step is to co-constructing a professional development plan that is grounded in the assessment of preferred modalities.
Through these 3 steps, school counselor in our country might have more professional power to help their clients (teachers) conceptualizing a student’s behavior, reduce the teacher’s stress and change the classroom system effectively.

Consulting and collaboration with teachers (cont. school-based consultation)

To help the teachers enhance their professional skills and to generalize the effects of psychoeducational intervention, consultants can use social dynamic information to support the direct interventions of teachers. The nature of the consultation relationship and its influence on the teacher determine the teacher is going to follow the consultation’s recommendations or not and implement the interventions.
Teachers are willing to follow the consultation’s recommendations if consultant
being based in the school
consultation services being offered rather than waiting for requests
the teachers perceiving that the consultant has excellent problem-solving skills
the teacher perceiving that they themselves have good problem-solving skills

Consulting high school teachers may vary from that elementary teacher as high school students have more than one teacher a day, consultant are more likely engage in group consultation.

When to consultant?

Effective consultation can often lead to a better and more acceptable scheme or policy. It can also save time and money. These tips will help you on your way:

◆ Consult before the decision is taken

Consultation is successful only when you are honest and transparent about the reasons the consultation is taking place. Do not consult for the sake of it. If you do not need or are unlikely to use the response, then ask yourself if you should be doing it at all.

◆ Timescale

Find out when the decision needs to be made and plan your consultation schedule accordingly. In most cases, it will be up to the individual manager to decide when the consultation should take place, except for some statutory requirements, such as planning applications, which set their own timescales.

◆ Planning

Allowing enough time for your consultation is critical. There are many stages to cover,
for example:

◆ drafting and testing questionnaires
◆ setting up meetings
◆ marketing or publicity (including the lead-in times necessary for
the council’s residents’ magazine WFM)
◆ staff time for administrative tasks
◆ giving consultees time to respond, in particular for written
consultation documents
◆ evaluation
◆ analysis of results
◆ presenting results

Consult when it is appropriate, necessary or relevant, for example:

◆ when you want to know what customers want from a service
◆ when a new service or policy initiative is being considered
◆ when you want to know if customers think our services are good
◆ when you want to make service improvements
◆ when you want to identify service users and who the potential users
could be
◆ when setting objectives and targets

school-based consultation

School-based intervention can be conceptualized as involving indirect service, direct service or both. School psychologists, school counselors and school social workers are the primary providers of consultation services. The goals are to change students’ behavior or the behavior of the adults involved with students. Furthermore, counselors and psychologists based in schools have been increasingly to assist collaboration related to the organization change necessitated by several factors.
School psychologists and counselors can help resolve concerns, prevent future problems and provide developmental strategies by consulting and collaborating with students. They also asked to provide consultation and collaboration services to improve schools in these specific areas:-
1. teaching, learning and related standards
2. use of technology
3. governance, management and accountability
4. parent and community support and involvement
5. make improvements system wide
6. promoting grassroots efforts
7. dropout prevention strategies
8. coordination with school-to-work programs
9. milestones and timelines
School-based psychologists and counselors should understand how to communicate with teachers, administrators and parents. Moreover, they must be aware of the forces operating in the local building, school system level and in the community of large.

mental health consultation


Few weeks ago, our class had divided into few groups to discuss about the mental health consultation. My group is discussing about the consultee-centered administrative consultation process. From what I have learned is the goal of consultee-centered administrative consultation is to enhance the professional competency of an administrative staff. The primary goal is an increased level of ministrative consultees’ functioning with regard to program development and organization and they help the institution accomplish its mission in the future.
For the consultant function and roles, the consultant is expected to be long term depending on the size of the consultee institution and the nature of the requested consultation. Furthermore, the consultant must be able to understand how these skills relate to individuals and subgroups within the consultee institution. The last one is the consultant must have the ability to scan the entire organization and make quick judgments about portions of the organization to examine in more depth.
Finally, the consultant have to determining who the consultee are, he or she must enters the organization to perform relationship-building activities, studies the social system of the institution, plan an intervention, intervene at the individual, group or organization level, evaluate and finally follow up.

Teacher Consultation Process – Consutee-Centered

Key stages of the process are outlined below:

INITIAL INTERVIEW
The consultant meets with the teacher, clarifies the confidential nature of their relationship, explains the process, and identifies a specific class on which to concentrate. If the teacher agrees to participate, the consultant arranges to begin collecting data.

DATA COLLECTION
The consultant interviews the teacher, observes him/her teaching the class, videotapes an instructional session (optional), and administers a questionnaire to the students in the class to obtain information about the instructor's(teacher) teaching behaviors.

DATA REVIEW AND ANALYSIS
The consultant and the teacher review the collected data. They identify strengths and areas that could be improved.

PLANNING AND IMPLEMENTING CHANGES
The consultant and the teacher identify three or four teaching improvement goals. The consultant helps the teacher design and implement strategies to meet these objectives.

EVALUATION
The consultant and teacher evaluate the process's success.

Myrick's Systematic Facilitative Approach to Consultation

Step 1: Identitfy the ProblemBe a listener. Help the consultee to tell about the situation.

Step 2: Clarify the Consultee's SituationBe a selective listener, giving attention to the following:
- Feelings - consultee's and client's
- Specific behaviors - consultee's and client's
- Consultee's expectations in the situation
- What the consultee has done up to this point
- Positive consultee attitudes and behaviors

Step 3: Identify the Goals or OutcomesSpecify the outsomes in observable behaviors.

Step 4: Observe and Record Behaviors

Step 5: Develop a Plan of Action - The Consultee's Intervention This is usually something that can be done within the next two weeks.

Step 6: Consultee Initiates the Plan

Step 7: Follow-Up

SUPPORTING PARENT & TEACHER CONSULTATION

CONSULTATION is a collaborative partnership in which the counselor works with parents, teachers, administrators, school psychologists, social workers, visiting teachers, medical professionals and community health personnel in order to plan and implement strategies to help students be successful in the education system. (American School Counselor Association, 1990, p. 1).

The counselor as a consultant primarily helps parents and teachers to be more effective in working with others. Consultation helps parents and teachers think through problems and concerns, acquire more knowledge and skills, and become more objective and self-confident.

This intervention can take place in individual or group conferences, through staff-development activities, or parent educational workshops. The consultation provides information and skills to parents/guardians, teachers, and the community to assist them in helping students in academic, career, and personal/social development.

The school counselor functions in a cooperative process to assist others to effectively meet the needs of students. Through consultation the school counselor advocates for students.

The counselor understands and knows how to:
1] Consult with parents, faculty, staff, administrators, and others to enhance their work with
students.
2] Interpret relevant information concerning the developmental needs of students.
3] Reduce barriers to student learning through direct referred services.
4] Facilitate new student integration into the school environment.
5] Work with teachers to provide support for students in a crisis situation.
6] Interact with school councils, school boards, Family Resource/Youth
7] Service Center Advisory Councils, and/or school committees.
8] Facilitate successful communication between and among teachers, parents, teacher and
students.
9] Work with teachers and administrators relevant to behavior management to promote and
support intervention strategies.
10] Consult with external community and professional resources.

Behavior Consultation

WHAT WE DO

Behavior Consultation:
Professional behavior specialists assisting individuals an d families to identify,
establish and attain achievable goals through simple behavior modification methods.

Behavior:
Any action taken based on thoughts or feelings in order to attain our needs or desires.

Individual Behavior Program:
A program designed by a behavior specialist, the staff, and the family, to increase, decrease, or change certain behaviors.

Behavior Training:
Behavior techniques taught to all staff and family members by the behavior specialist and direct supp ort staff.

Family Support:
Professional support specialists work with families to achieve their goals and provide flexible approaches to meet each family’s unique needs.

Individual Family Support Pro gram:
A program designed by a family with a DSPD (Department of Services for People with Disabilities) Family Supp ort coordinator to address the real issues that family members face daily. The family decides which goals will be addressed and then the family is presented with suggested methods of accomplishing the goals. These are the support strategies that Frontline Service s will
use to assist the family. All final decisions are made by the family. Frontline staff are always available to assist the family.

Residential Services:
Professional Direct Sup port Staff assist individuals who decide to live outside o f their parents ho me, institution, group home , or intermediate care facility. Many of these individuals receive 24hour care, special medical services, behavior assistance, and a variety of other services based on their specific needs and desires.

Person-Centered Planning:
A program designed by the individual, with assistance from family, friends, state support coordinator and support staff. This Person-Centered plan is designed to assist the individual with realizing their ideas, hopes and dreams.



Support Strategies:
Specific strategies to assist the individual with attaining their ideas, hopes, and dreams. Techniques taught to all staff and family members by Frontline Service’s teachers, behavior specialists and direct supp ort staff.

Personal Outcome Measures:
A system designed to measure an individuals realization o f their ideas, hopes, and dreams. Emphasis on individual rights and quality of life are essential parts of this ongoing assessment.

Family Involvement:
At Frontline Services we strive to keep families together. Most children move out on their own eventually but that doesn’t mean that communication
needs to stop. We work closely with the individual’s family to ensure their vision of the future remain intact.

Mental Health Consultation

Three Popular Models of Consultation

  • Organizational
  • Mental Health
  • Behavioral

Organizational Consultation

  • Enhances the overall effectiveness of the organization in some way (e.g., designing an orientation process for general medical patients in a multidisciplinary clinic who are referred for mental health counseling).
  • Organizational Consultation
  • Uses a series of approaches:
  • Purchase-of-Expertise
  • Educational and Training Consultation
  • Program Consultation
  • Doctor-Patient
  • Process Consultation
    (Schein, 1988)


Mental Health Consultation

  • Enhances the psychological well-being of the parties involved (e.g., crisis intervention with classmates and staff after a student’s death in a head-on collision a block from school).
  • Mental Health Consultation
  • Uses:
    --Case consultation
    --Program consultation
  • To improve consultee’s ability to perform better in the future (Caplan & Caplan, 1993)


Behavioral Consultation

  • Seeks to bring about specific changes in the client and client system
  • Seeks to bring about specific changes in the consultee


Behavioral Consultation

  • Uses behavioral technology and social learning theory
  • Aims for specific changes in behavior
  • Sets specific goals (see Bergin & Kratchowill, 1990)


Putting It All Together…

  • What model do you use for your theoretical orientation (e.g., psychodynamic? humanistic? Adlerian? social learning?)
  • Given that model, which mode is appropriate? (e.g., prescriptive? doctor-patient? collaborative? etc.)
  • Which roles are best assumed in this approach? (e.g., planner, facilitator, expert…)

Characteristics of Consultation

Characteristics of Consultation

  1. It uses a problem-solving process (see McClam and Woodside’s problem-solving applications in human services; Krumboltz’s problem-solving in helping relationships)
  2. It is triadic (consultant, consultee, client/client system)
  3. It has remedial and preventive goals (i.e., can address primary, secondary, tertiary prevention)
  4. Consultant can be either internal or external to the system served
  5. Participation in consultation is voluntary
  6. The peer relationship between consultant and consultee tends to be collaborative whenever possib
  7. The consultative relationship is a temporary one (the consultant tries to put him- or herself out of a job by improving the consultee’s ability to function without the consultant when similar problems are encountered in the future)
  8. Consultation can be remedial (that is, it can be used to solve a problem)
  9. Consultation can be developmental (that is, it can be used to help a client reach full potential)

Common Consultant Roles


Advocate

Expert

Trainer/Educator

Collaborator

Fact Finder
Process
Specialist

Planner

Motivator

Facilitator

Journal Review - 2

LITERATURE REVIEW

DESCRIPTOR/S: Ezatul Arni bt. Zolkpli
AUTHOR/S: Elysia Clemens
YEAR: April 2007
TITLE:
Developmental Counseling and Therapy as a Model for School Counselor Consultation with Teachers

LITERATURE REVIEW:
Consulting with teachers is one way that school counselors can efficiently respond to some referrals while also providing system support. Using a developmental counseling and therapy-based consultation model, school counselors can assess how a teacher is conceptualizing a student's behavior, respond to the stress a teacher may feel connected to that behavior, and indirectly effect change in a classroom system. Through consultation with a teacher, school counselors can target the individual who is most likely in a position to effect change in the classroom environment. If a teacher implements changes that make the classroom system function more effectively, then the frequency or intensity of some student behaviors may decrease (Marzano & Marzano, 2003). Changing the system not only may help a student to make immediate behavioral changes but also might help a student to sustain those changes (Ivey, 1991). Furthermore, classroom management affects not only the student identified in the referral but also the class as a whole and has a substantial effect on students' achievement.
INTERPRETATIONS OF FINDINGS:
Some teachers may seek consultation when they feel stress related to a student's behavior or patterns of disruptive or inappropriate behavior in their classroom. The reality, however, is that teaching can be a lonely and isolating profession (Schlichte, Yssel, & Merbler, 2005), and it is likely that some teachers feel stress but do not ask directly for help. Because written referral documents are one way that school counselors encourage teachers to communicate their needs, considering both the content and stylistic aspects of these student referral documents in the context of historical referral data from each teacher might be helpful in determining when to reach out to teachers and offer consultation.
Sensorimotor-like characteristics emerging in written referrals might be a window into the stress a teacher is experiencing in relation to the student's behavior. For example, fragmented or exaggerated writing styles, such as short disconnected sentences or the use of multiple underlines, exclamation points, and all-capital letters, might reflect the emotions a teacher experienced while writing the referral. Comparing the current referral to other referral documents written by the same teacher may be helpful to contextualize the writing style of the referral. If the sensorimotor-like characteristics of a written referral diverge substantially from past referrals made by a teacher, it may serve as an indicator of the teacher's stress level and checking in with that teacher could be helpful.
Conversely, characteristics associated with the concrete developmental modality may mask a teacher's stress level. A referral document that includes a detailed linear account of a classroom event might not include allusions to the teacher's affective experience. It is likely that a teacher utilizing the concrete modality to make sense out of a classroom event is separating his or her emotions from the experience. Multiple referrals based on similar student behavior from one teacher, however, might suggest that there may be a systemic or stressrelated component to the referral that can be addressed through consultation (Brigman et al., 2005) despite the teacher's presentation as an objective observer of student behavior.
Absolute language such as "always" that punctuates the formal-operational cognitive developmental modality might be considered in the context of the pattern of referrals (or lack of referrals) received in reference to an individual student. If multiple teachers report that a student frequently engages in a particular set of inappropriate or disruptive behaviors, then working directly with that student or with a team of his or her teachers might be more appropriate than consulting individually with one teacher. Alternatively, absolute language that does not fit contextually with other teachers' reports may be an indicator of an individual teacher's difficulty managing a particular student's behavior or type of student behavior in the classroom. Functional behavioral assessments are also a good resource, when available, for determining the frequency and intensity of a student's behavior across classrooms (Kampwirth, 2006).
Consultation is not an appropriate response to all teachers' referrals or requests for individual counseling. Consultation, however, might be particularly helpful when there are factors indicating that providing support to a teacher in an effort to help him or her directly facilitate change might positively impact not only the referred student but also groups of students (e.g., a class). Ultimately, a school counselor's choice to offer DCT-based consultation to a teacher who refers a student for counseling should be guided by a determination of whether or not the teacher is limited in his or her conceptualization of the situation.
CONCLUSIONS:
A DCT-based consultation model provides a practical and efficient approach to consulting with teachers. The DCT model for consultation is an assessment, used to simultaneously understand a problem and also the consultee's range of access to the four cognitive developmental modalities. It is also an intervention that can facilitate a teacher's access to more cognitive developmental modalities and direct future professional development. DCT-based consultation can help school counselors to maximize their time and provide support to teachers while also empowering teachers to effect positive change in their classrooms.

My Journal Review

DESCRIPTOR/S: Ezatul Arni bt. Zolkpli
AUTHOR/S: Asha K Jitendra, George J DuPaul, Robert J Volpe, and Katy E Tresco.
YEAR: Jun 2007
TITLE:
Consultation-Based Academic Intervention for Children With Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder: School Functioning Outcomes

LITERATURE REVIEW:
This study evaluated the effectiveness of two consultation-based models for designing academic interventions to enhance the educational functioning of children with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. In most public school settings, teachers work in collaboration with others, such as a consultant (e.g., school psychologist), to plan classroom interventions, with the teacher selecting a specific treatment strategy, presumably based on both perceived effectiveness and feasibility of the various intervention options. A data-based consultation decisionmaking model (Daly, Witt, Martens, & Dool, 1997; Sheridan, Kratochwill, & Bergan, 1996) is known to improve educational outcomes. This consultation model entails classroom teachers working with consultants to develop individualized interventions based on initial performance data, which consider student strengths and weaknesses as well as important contextual variables (e.g., antecedent and consequent events prompting and maintaining behaviors) related to the target behavior. In addition, consultants monitor treatment implementation and provide teachers with feedback designed to enhance intervention fidelity.
The purpose of this study was to compare the effects of two different models of school-based consultation on the academic functioning of a large sample of students with ADHD. One approach involved consultation using customary or traditional levels of data utilization, wherein teachers selected academic interventions proposed by a school psychologist or special educator based on perceived effectiveness and feasibility, with minimal follow-up once interventions had been implemented. The other consultation approach, which was deemed intensive in data utilization, involved the selection and development of academic interventions based on data collected by the consultant regarding individual student skills and present classroom conditions. Teachers also were provided with feedback regarding treatment integrity and interventions were modified based on outcome data. Potential interventions (e.g., peer tutoring, direct instruction, and computer-assisted instruction) used in both groups were empirically supported by prior single subject research studies. It was hypothesized that the children receiving individualized academic interventions would exhibit greater growth in academic achievement as measured by report card grades, CBM mathematics and reading tests, and teacher ratings of changes in target skills than would children whose interventions were selected in the context of a typical school-based consultation model.
INTERPRETATIONS OF FINDINGS:
This study compared the effects of two different consultation models (TDAI and IDAI) on the academic achievement of children with ADHD. Specifically, we examined school functioning as measured by CBM assessments, report card grades, and individual goal attainment (i.e., POTB). The results indicated that the two consultation groups did not differ with respect to growth on any of the academic measures.
At the same time, the finding about a positive outcome for the TDAI group on the POTB combined with the fact that interventions designed through the IDAI approach were implemented with greater integrity than those designed through the TDAI approach is not consistent with research that clearly indicates a link between treatment integrity and outcome (Witt & Elliott, 1985). One explanation for the finding may be that TDAI teachers, on average, implemented academic strategies with a sufficient level of integrity to produce positive outcomes. The level of integrity with the TDAI intervention was greater than 50% integrity, which is higher than previous findings for behavioral interventions under similar no-feedback conditions. In contrast, a small effect was found for math report card grades for both groups. On the report card grade for reading, the effect was small for the IDAI group and medium for the TDAI group. A plausible hypothesis is that report card grades are relatively stable across time (Guskey, 2005). Further, it may be the case that the mathematics skills targeted for intervention in both groups did not match the content addressed in the classroom. Because students in this study were those with serious academic deficits and were functioning below grade level as reported by their teachers, the majority of interventions in mathematics targeted remediation of basic skills (e.g., facts, operations) that were prerequisites for doing more complex math. However, grades in mathematics were based on information covered in grade level content (e.g., graphing) that may not have been mastered by these students.

CONCLUSIONS:

As a conclusion, in an age of accountability, schools are under increased pressure to improve student outcomes. Identifying effective instructional practices that enhance school functioning of children with high needs (e.g., ADHD) is essential. The consultation approaches in this study hold promise in meeting the goal of closing the achievement gap for these students. Contrary to the original hypothesis, results of the current study suggested that both IDAI and TDAI are comparable in improving the academic performance of students with ADHD. Even though an a priori power analysis suggested that the sample size was adequate, it is recommended that additional study of these two approaches be conducted with a larger sample size to increase confidence in the results. In addition, future research should examine possible differences in outcomes over longer periods of time. Finally, it is important to explore the conditions under which the TDAI consultation approach is sufficient and to identify the conditions in which more intensive IDAI consultation strategies are necessary.