DESCRIPTOR/S: Ezatul Arni bt. Zolkpli
AUTHOR/S: Asha K Jitendra, George J DuPaul, Robert J Volpe, and Katy E Tresco.
YEAR: Jun 2007
TITLE:
Consultation-Based Academic Intervention for Children With Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder: School Functioning Outcomes
LITERATURE REVIEW:
This study evaluated the effectiveness of two consultation-based models for designing academic interventions to enhance the educational functioning of children with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. In most public school settings, teachers work in collaboration with others, such as a consultant (e.g., school psychologist), to plan classroom interventions, with the teacher selecting a specific treatment strategy, presumably based on both perceived effectiveness and feasibility of the various intervention options. A data-based consultation decisionmaking model (Daly, Witt, Martens, & Dool, 1997; Sheridan, Kratochwill, & Bergan, 1996) is known to improve educational outcomes. This consultation model entails classroom teachers working with consultants to develop individualized interventions based on initial performance data, which consider student strengths and weaknesses as well as important contextual variables (e.g., antecedent and consequent events prompting and maintaining behaviors) related to the target behavior. In addition, consultants monitor treatment implementation and provide teachers with feedback designed to enhance intervention fidelity.
The purpose of this study was to compare the effects of two different models of school-based consultation on the academic functioning of a large sample of students with ADHD. One approach involved consultation using customary or traditional levels of data utilization, wherein teachers selected academic interventions proposed by a school psychologist or special educator based on perceived effectiveness and feasibility, with minimal follow-up once interventions had been implemented. The other consultation approach, which was deemed intensive in data utilization, involved the selection and development of academic interventions based on data collected by the consultant regarding individual student skills and present classroom conditions. Teachers also were provided with feedback regarding treatment integrity and interventions were modified based on outcome data. Potential interventions (e.g., peer tutoring, direct instruction, and computer-assisted instruction) used in both groups were empirically supported by prior single subject research studies. It was hypothesized that the children receiving individualized academic interventions would exhibit greater growth in academic achievement as measured by report card grades, CBM mathematics and reading tests, and teacher ratings of changes in target skills than would children whose interventions were selected in the context of a typical school-based consultation model.
INTERPRETATIONS OF FINDINGS:
This study compared the effects of two different consultation models (TDAI and IDAI) on the academic achievement of children with ADHD. Specifically, we examined school functioning as measured by CBM assessments, report card grades, and individual goal attainment (i.e., POTB). The results indicated that the two consultation groups did not differ with respect to growth on any of the academic measures.
At the same time, the finding about a positive outcome for the TDAI group on the POTB combined with the fact that interventions designed through the IDAI approach were implemented with greater integrity than those designed through the TDAI approach is not consistent with research that clearly indicates a link between treatment integrity and outcome (Witt & Elliott, 1985). One explanation for the finding may be that TDAI teachers, on average, implemented academic strategies with a sufficient level of integrity to produce positive outcomes. The level of integrity with the TDAI intervention was greater than 50% integrity, which is higher than previous findings for behavioral interventions under similar no-feedback conditions. In contrast, a small effect was found for math report card grades for both groups. On the report card grade for reading, the effect was small for the IDAI group and medium for the TDAI group. A plausible hypothesis is that report card grades are relatively stable across time (Guskey, 2005). Further, it may be the case that the mathematics skills targeted for intervention in both groups did not match the content addressed in the classroom. Because students in this study were those with serious academic deficits and were functioning below grade level as reported by their teachers, the majority of interventions in mathematics targeted remediation of basic skills (e.g., facts, operations) that were prerequisites for doing more complex math. However, grades in mathematics were based on information covered in grade level content (e.g., graphing) that may not have been mastered by these students.
CONCLUSIONS:
As a conclusion, in an age of accountability, schools are under increased pressure to improve student outcomes. Identifying effective instructional practices that enhance school functioning of children with high needs (e.g., ADHD) is essential. The consultation approaches in this study hold promise in meeting the goal of closing the achievement gap for these students. Contrary to the original hypothesis, results of the current study suggested that both IDAI and TDAI are comparable in improving the academic performance of students with ADHD. Even though an a priori power analysis suggested that the sample size was adequate, it is recommended that additional study of these two approaches be conducted with a larger sample size to increase confidence in the results. In addition, future research should examine possible differences in outcomes over longer periods of time. Finally, it is important to explore the conditions under which the TDAI consultation approach is sufficient and to identify the conditions in which more intensive IDAI consultation strategies are necessary.
AUTHOR/S: Asha K Jitendra, George J DuPaul, Robert J Volpe, and Katy E Tresco.
YEAR: Jun 2007
TITLE:
Consultation-Based Academic Intervention for Children With Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder: School Functioning Outcomes
LITERATURE REVIEW:
This study evaluated the effectiveness of two consultation-based models for designing academic interventions to enhance the educational functioning of children with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. In most public school settings, teachers work in collaboration with others, such as a consultant (e.g., school psychologist), to plan classroom interventions, with the teacher selecting a specific treatment strategy, presumably based on both perceived effectiveness and feasibility of the various intervention options. A data-based consultation decisionmaking model (Daly, Witt, Martens, & Dool, 1997; Sheridan, Kratochwill, & Bergan, 1996) is known to improve educational outcomes. This consultation model entails classroom teachers working with consultants to develop individualized interventions based on initial performance data, which consider student strengths and weaknesses as well as important contextual variables (e.g., antecedent and consequent events prompting and maintaining behaviors) related to the target behavior. In addition, consultants monitor treatment implementation and provide teachers with feedback designed to enhance intervention fidelity.
The purpose of this study was to compare the effects of two different models of school-based consultation on the academic functioning of a large sample of students with ADHD. One approach involved consultation using customary or traditional levels of data utilization, wherein teachers selected academic interventions proposed by a school psychologist or special educator based on perceived effectiveness and feasibility, with minimal follow-up once interventions had been implemented. The other consultation approach, which was deemed intensive in data utilization, involved the selection and development of academic interventions based on data collected by the consultant regarding individual student skills and present classroom conditions. Teachers also were provided with feedback regarding treatment integrity and interventions were modified based on outcome data. Potential interventions (e.g., peer tutoring, direct instruction, and computer-assisted instruction) used in both groups were empirically supported by prior single subject research studies. It was hypothesized that the children receiving individualized academic interventions would exhibit greater growth in academic achievement as measured by report card grades, CBM mathematics and reading tests, and teacher ratings of changes in target skills than would children whose interventions were selected in the context of a typical school-based consultation model.
INTERPRETATIONS OF FINDINGS:
This study compared the effects of two different consultation models (TDAI and IDAI) on the academic achievement of children with ADHD. Specifically, we examined school functioning as measured by CBM assessments, report card grades, and individual goal attainment (i.e., POTB). The results indicated that the two consultation groups did not differ with respect to growth on any of the academic measures.
At the same time, the finding about a positive outcome for the TDAI group on the POTB combined with the fact that interventions designed through the IDAI approach were implemented with greater integrity than those designed through the TDAI approach is not consistent with research that clearly indicates a link between treatment integrity and outcome (Witt & Elliott, 1985). One explanation for the finding may be that TDAI teachers, on average, implemented academic strategies with a sufficient level of integrity to produce positive outcomes. The level of integrity with the TDAI intervention was greater than 50% integrity, which is higher than previous findings for behavioral interventions under similar no-feedback conditions. In contrast, a small effect was found for math report card grades for both groups. On the report card grade for reading, the effect was small for the IDAI group and medium for the TDAI group. A plausible hypothesis is that report card grades are relatively stable across time (Guskey, 2005). Further, it may be the case that the mathematics skills targeted for intervention in both groups did not match the content addressed in the classroom. Because students in this study were those with serious academic deficits and were functioning below grade level as reported by their teachers, the majority of interventions in mathematics targeted remediation of basic skills (e.g., facts, operations) that were prerequisites for doing more complex math. However, grades in mathematics were based on information covered in grade level content (e.g., graphing) that may not have been mastered by these students.
CONCLUSIONS:
As a conclusion, in an age of accountability, schools are under increased pressure to improve student outcomes. Identifying effective instructional practices that enhance school functioning of children with high needs (e.g., ADHD) is essential. The consultation approaches in this study hold promise in meeting the goal of closing the achievement gap for these students. Contrary to the original hypothesis, results of the current study suggested that both IDAI and TDAI are comparable in improving the academic performance of students with ADHD. Even though an a priori power analysis suggested that the sample size was adequate, it is recommended that additional study of these two approaches be conducted with a larger sample size to increase confidence in the results. In addition, future research should examine possible differences in outcomes over longer periods of time. Finally, it is important to explore the conditions under which the TDAI consultation approach is sufficient and to identify the conditions in which more intensive IDAI consultation strategies are necessary.
No comments:
Post a Comment