What is Real Collaboration?
Before discussing this topic in greater depth, it is useful to define the subject’s often-overused terms,distinguishing their specialized nonprofit meanings from their more common Standard English usage:
The standard English terms (lower case “c”) collaboration, and collaborative refer to
the means through which individuals or organizations work together in a concerted
effort toward mutually desired ends. (E.g. “Through collaboration we hope to
achieve our mutual goals.” Or, “Working collaboratively, community members
solved their problems.”)
vs.
The specialized, nonprofit usage of the terms (for our purposes indicated by use of a
capital “C”) Collaboration and Collaborative refer to the creation of a more formal
and semi-permanent structure that supports the type of collaboration described above.
This usage involves the ungrammatical reification of the previously simpler terms.
(E.g. “I am going to a meeting of the Collaborative.” Or, “We are now actively
funding Collaboration.”).
In this monograph, capitalization is used to signify the specialized meaning just described.
Almost all nonprofits, by the very nature of their public benefit activities, collaborate with other
nonprofits on a variety of issues. Nonprofits may work together on a joint lobbying effort to gain morefunds from local government, they may desire to reduce costs through joint purchasing activities, or theymay simply engage in the ongoing mutual support and helpfulness nonprofit managers extend to one another in order to keep their sanity while doing a difficult job. These simple and necessary forms of collaboration are “real” in that they are honest; they purport to be what they really are. These common collaborative activities are voluntary and informal. It is significant that they are also usually somewhat tangential. That is, they are removed from the core programmatic or operational activities of the entities and are thus less threatening to that lifeblood of the nonprofit enterprise: organizational autonomy. The case with program-focused Collaboration and Collaboratives is not so simple. As grantmakers encourage or demand collaborative action on the part of their grantees, they receive one of two possible responses. The first, and apparently the most common response, is for the grantees to create the “appearance of collaboration” by forming a group they will call a Collaborative. The collaborative then holds a series of meetings leading to the members jointly writing a grant proposal to the funder. This approach often masks the fact that the parties have little stomach for integrating or even coordinating their services, and intend to use the jointly raised money to continue working separately. In other words, Collaboration may be simply another way of gaining grant support. Much like a challenge grant, a matching grant, or any other restricted purpose foundation grant, a Collaborative grant may be viewed by grantees as another way of getting money. Indeed, they may see it as one with some particularly onerous strings attached. The second, rarer response to funder encouragement is for the grantees to meet, honestly recognize the possible synergies of working together, and begin to coordinate programmatic and other core efforts more closely. This is Real Collaboration. It is a rare response to funder encouragement because it is difficult for a grantmaker to instill in its grantees a genuine motivation to undertake such a partnership. This is particularly true when grantmaking is tied to collaboration. It is perhaps most difficult to build a collaborative relationship if the impulse for partnership arises during the hectic period of responding to a funder’s Request for Proposals.
Says one experienced funder of collaboration:
For the past eight years our foundation has maintained a Collaboration fund to which our grantees could apply. I would say about 75% of these grants have failed to produce anything. They have just been a different way for the grantees to get money from us. In the other 25%, where something has in fact developed, these are almost always situations where there was already a spark of collaboration and our money just helped to fan it into a flame.For many reasons, Real Collaboration is by all accounts far less common than the appearance of collaboration. Some of these reasons will be covered in the next section. Our purpose here has been principally to distinguish and define Real Collaboration, which is what most grantmakers have in mind when they use the “C” word.
I got it from internet, 1 whole book with 31 pages. Maybe we can share it together.
Wednesday, October 3, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment